Home › Construction Administration › Supplemental Instructions (SI)
CA FIELD GUIDE · 05
Supplemental Instructions (SI), Site Instructions & ASIs
The SI is the tool you'll use most during construction, and the one that's easiest to get wrong. Here's what it is, what it isn't, and how to package one properly.
THE SHORT ANSWER
A supplemental instruction (SI) is the architect's written direction that clarifies or adjusts the work without changing the contract price or contract time. Under CCDC 2 in Canada it's a Supplemental Instruction, and most people on site call it a site instruction. In the US, under AIA A201, the equivalent is an ASI (Architect's Supplemental Instruction). If the instruction costs money or time, it's not an SI anymore; it's a CCN or change order.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- The test: does it change price or time? No = SI. Maybe = CCN. Yes, and urgent = change directive.
- Reissue the whole revised sheet, clouded, not an 8.5×11 sketch.
- Accepting a contractor's alternate? Issue an SI at no cost to the owner.
- If the contractor says "extra," don't argue in email. Review the scope fairly.
What is a supplemental instruction?
A supplemental instruction is the architect's written direction that clarifies or adjusts the work without changing the contract price or the contract time. It's how a revised detail, a coordination fix or an RFI answer that changes the drawings gets onto the record and into the contractor's hands.
SI vs. site instruction vs. ASI: which is it?
| Term | Where you'll see it | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| SI – Supplemental Instruction | CCDC 2 (Canada) | Instruction from the Consultant with no change to price or time |
| Site Instruction | What most of us say on site | Same thing. On my jobs, SI and site instruction mean the same document. |
| ASI – Architect's Supplemental Instruction | AIA A201 (US); CM and developer jobs | Minor change or clarification with no change to contract sum or time |
The label matters less than the test: does this change price or time? If no, it's an SI. If maybe, it's a proposed change. If yes and the work can't wait, it's a change directive.
When to use an SI
- An RFI answer that revises a drawing or detail
- A coordination fix between disciplines
- A clarification of what's already in the contract
- An owner tweak with genuinely no cost, like swapping one specified colour for another
- A contractor-proposed alternate you'll accept at no cost to the owner
SIs on CM and developer jobs
On a construction management or developer-led project, you often won't issue proposed changes at all. You issue ASIs with the drawing changes, and the money is handled between the owner and the CM. On a stipulated-sum job, you'll juggle SIs and CCNs side by side. Read your contract before you pick the document.
How to package and issue an SI
- Know what you're changing. Usually it's a drawing change.
- Change the drawings. Revise in CAD or Revit, cloud it and add the revision to the title block.
- Issue the sheet. We used to clip the change onto an 8.5×11 architectural sketch (an "ASK"). These days everyone on site has an iPad, so reissue the whole revised sheet. No fiddling, and the set stays current.
- Write the instruction. Number it, say what's changing and why, reference the RFI that triggered it, and state plainly: no change to contract price or time.
- Distribute and log. To the contractor and every affected consultant.
- Ask the contractor to flag cost or time within the contract's notice period. If they do, convert it to a CCN.
WATCH
Construction drawings on site: are you using the latest set?
The SI that's secretly a change
It happens. You issue an SI thinking it's free and the contractor writes back, "This is an extra." Don't fight it in an email thread. Look at the scope honestly. If they're right, convert it to a CCN and price it. If they're wrong, say why with reference to the contract documents. Either way, keep the trail.
In Project Arc, that conversion is the same record: the SI becomes a change notice, the contractor's pricing comes back into it, and nobody retypes a number.
WATCH
What is a change directive?
BUILT BY THE HOST OF WHAT THE RFI?
Issue it once. Keep the set current.
In Project Arc, you issue site instructions and change notices straight from the project record. The revised sheet slip-sheets into the current set automatically, with every version comparable side by side. If an SI turns out to cost money, the contractor's pricing comes back into the same record and can be approved into a change order.
- Site instructions issued from the project record
- Arc Slip-Sheet for automatic drawing updates
- GC pricing returned into the same record
- Approve into a change order without retyping
Full disclosure: I built Project Arc. One project. Every phase. projectarc.io
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
What is a supplemental instruction in construction?
A written instruction from the architect or consultant that clarifies or adjusts the work without changing the contract price or contract time.
What is the difference between an SI and an ASI?
SI (Supplemental Instruction) is the CCDC 2 term used in Canada. ASI (Architect's Supplemental Instruction) is the AIA term used in the US and common on CM jobs. Both are direction with no price or time change.
Is a site instruction the same as a supplemental instruction?
In practice, yes. Many people on site say site instruction for the CCDC 2 Supplemental Instruction.
Can a supplemental instruction add cost?
No. If it adds cost or time, it should be handled as a proposed change (CCN), change directive or change order.
What if the contractor disputes an SI?
Review the scope fairly. If it's a genuine extra, convert it to a CCN. If the work must proceed before price is agreed, consider a change directive.
KEEP GOING
Episodes & articles on this topic
- The Art of Issuing Site Instructions & Proposed Changes (episode)
- Site instructions vs. proposed changes
- The challenges with change directives
- Why up-to-date drawings on site matter
- CA 101: essential terminology
MORE CA FIELD GUIDES
How many RFIs did you get this week?
Got a CA question you want answered on the show? Send it in. Architects keep designing, contractors keep making those blueprints a reality.
