Home › Construction Administration › Shop Drawings & Submittals

CA FIELD GUIDE · 04

Shop Drawings & Submittals: The Architect's Review Guide

Submittals are how the contractor shows you what they're about to fabricate, buy or install before it shows up on site. Here's what to ask for, how to review it, and what your stamp actually means.

Mastering shop drawings: samples, mock-ups and the review stamp.

THE SHORT ANSWER

Shop drawings and submittals are documents and samples the contractor sends to the design team before fabrication or installation: shop drawings, product data, samples and mock-ups. The architect and consultants review them for general conformance with the design intent. Review doesn't relieve the contractor of responsibility for dimensions, quantities, coordination or means and methods.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • Unlike RFIs, submittals are predictable. Your specs call every one of them up.
  • The contractor reviews, coordinates and stamps first. You're not their QC department.
  • Ask for the samples you need, not everything.
  • A shop drawing isn't the place to change the design.

What are shop drawings and submittals?

You specified the toilet, the bleachers, the curtain wall and the paint colour. Submittals are where you check that's what's actually coming, before it shows up on site.

Here's the nice thing compared to RFIs: you can predict submittals. You can't know how many RFIs a job will bring, but every submittal is called up in your specifications. Ask the contractor for a submittal schedule early and plan your review time around it.

The four kinds of submittal

TypeWhat it isWhat to check
Shop drawingsFabrication and installation drawings by the trade: steel, millwork, curtain wall, precast, sprinklersDesign intent, interfaces with other work, clouded deviations
Product dataCut sheets and manufacturer literatureSpecified product, model and options, clearly highlighted
SamplesPhysical pieces: paint drawdowns, veneer, glass, stainColour, finish and grain against your design
Mock-upsA built section on site: exposed concrete, masonry panelThe quality standard everyone agrees to before the big pour

Samples: ask for what you need, not everything

I've had paint drawdowns come in a totally different tint from the colour deck, and that's exactly why we ask. That drawdown is what they're painting your school with.

But be smart about it. Do you need a door frame sample? No. I once had a full curtain wall sample shipped to my office, mullions and all. I know what a mullion looks like. Same with a big sheet of corrugated metal. I can look out my window and see corrugated. Then the real pain in the butt is what you do with it afterwards.

Contractor review comes first

Before a submittal ever reaches you, the contractor should have reviewed it, checked field dimensions, coordinated with the other trades and stamped it. If it shows up unstamped or obviously unchecked, send it back.

How the submittal review works

  1. Receive and log. Number it, date it, check it's complete.
  2. Route. Architectural stays with you. Structural, mechanical and electrical go to the right consultant, and the prime consolidates.
  3. Review for design intent and general conformance. You are not re-checking every dimension.
  4. Stamp and comment. Typical stamps: Reviewed, Reviewed as noted, Revise and resubmit, Rejected.
  5. Return and track. Log resubmittals. A third round on the same submittal means it's time to pick up the phone.

What your review stamp means (and doesn't)

Review doesn't take responsibility off the contractor. They're still on the hook for dimensions, quantities, fabrication, coordination between trades, and means and methods. Your review checks general conformance with the design intent. Read the wording on your firm's stamp; it's there for a reason.

Deviations, substitutions and the sneaky change

A shop drawing is not the place to change the design. If the trade has swapped a product or changed a detail, it should be clouded and called out. If it isn't and you catch it, reject that part. If the change is real and acceptable, it goes through the proper route: a substitution request, a supplemental instruction or a change order.

You've heard me say it on the show: I'm not a fan of alternates showing up after award. If one makes the schedule work, fine. The contractor carries any knock-on cost.

WATCH

The steel detailer's perspective

What the people drawing your shop drawings actually need from you.

Keeping the submittal log honest

Due dates, ball-in-court and the resubmittal history are what keep reviews from stalling, especially when the hold-up is a consultant, not you. In Project Arc, submittals and shop drawings live in the same register as your RFIs, linked to the sheets they touch, so you can see at a glance whose desk it's sitting on.

BUILT BY THE HOST OF WHAT THE RFI?

Every submittal, with a clear ball-in-court.

In Project Arc, RFIs, submittals and shop drawings live in one register, each linked to the sheets it touches, with due dates and a clear ball-in-court. Revised drawings slip-sheet into the current set automatically, and every version stays comparable side by side.

  • One register for submittals, shop drawings and RFIs
  • Due dates and ball-in-court for every consultant
  • Arc Slip-Sheet keeps the current set current
  • Old sheets stay on file, clearly marked

Full disclosure: I built Project Arc. One project. Every phase. projectarc.io

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

What is a shop drawing in construction?

A shop drawing is a detailed fabrication or installation drawing prepared by a trade or supplier, such as structural steel, millwork or curtain wall, and submitted for the design team's review before fabrication.

What is the difference between a shop drawing and a submittal?

Submittal is the umbrella term. Shop drawings are one type, alongside product data, samples and mock-ups.

Who reviews shop drawings?

The contractor reviews and stamps them first, then the architect and relevant consultants review them for general conformance with the design intent.

Does a reviewed shop drawing mean every dimension is checked?

No. Dimensions, quantities and trade coordination remain the contractor's responsibility.

How long should a shop drawing review take?

Whatever your Division 01 specifies. Use the submittal schedule to plan review time.

What does revise and resubmit mean?

The submittal doesn't conform as submitted. The contractor corrects it and resubmits, clouding the changes.

How many RFIs did you get this week?

Got a CA question you want answered on the show? Send it in. Architects keep designing, contractors keep making those blueprints a reality.

How many RFIs did you get this week?

Have a Construction Administration question, a podcast topic you’d like us to cover, or are you interested in being a guest, speaking opportunity, or sponsorship? We’d love to hear from you.